Ancillary Reviews

Some studies involve activities that require specialized review outside of the IRB.  For example, when a study involves the transfer of gene material into humans, the protocol must undergo review by the Einstein Institutional Biosafety Committee (IBC). We refer to these as Ancillary Reviews, or Committee Reviews.  Some ancillary reviews affect subject safety; therefore the IRB cannot approve a study until the ancillary review is complete.  The research team is responsible for applying to the ancillary committee or reviewing applicable policies to ensure compliance with institutional requirements. If the ancillary review impacts subject safety or the ability to conduct the research successfully, the IRB will require proof of the ancillary committee’s determination as part of the application for initial review. The list below is separated into three sections to assist you in understanding how the requirement will affect your IRB application and review process.

The following committee approvals are required before the IRB may review a study:

Committee Name Required For Contact
Einstein Institutional Biosafety Committee (IBC) Any research involving the transfer of gene material, complementary DNA, full length genes, RNA, or oligonucleotides into humans Dr. D.Y. Goldstein
718.920.2149
Cancer Center Protocol Review and Monitoring Committee (PRMC) Any Montefiore Einstein research involving a primarily cancer patient population. Note: Studies receiving “expedited” review by the PRMC may be reviewed by the IRB prior to PRMC approval, but IRB approval will not be issued until after the PRMC approves. prmc@montefiore.org
718.379.6861

The following committee approvals are required before the IRB may issue an approval on a study:

Committee Name Required For Contact
Clinical Research Center Protocol Review Committee (CRC PRC) Any research utilizing the CRC facilities Elizabeth Catro
718.920.5126
Vishwa Niranjan
718.430.2763
Radiation Safety Committee (RSC) Any research involving radiation or radioisotopes beyond standard clinical care at Montefiore Einstein Manyu Chen
718.920.5012
Radiation Safety Committee (RSC) at Jacobi Any research involving radiation or radioisotopes beyond standard clinical care at Jacobi Lionel Zuckier
718.9187.4897
Hazardous Materials Committee Any research involving Acutely toxic materials (e.g., arsenic, cyanide), Neurotoxic materials (e.g., MPTP), Carcinogens (e.g., ENU, MNU, formaldehyde, azoxymethane), Mutagens/teratogens (e.g., BrdU), Heavy metals (e.g., mercury, cadmium, chromium, silver, lead), Other chemicals that may be toxic to target organs (e.g., streptozotocin, carbon tetrachloride), Chemotherapy agents (e.g., mitoxantrone, 5-FU), Waste anesthetic gases (e.g., isoflurane, halothane), Other regulated chemicals (e.g., EPA P-list or U-listed, OSHA toxic and hazardous substances), or if unsure email. ehs@montefiore.org
718.920.7600
Occupational Health Services at Montefiore COVID research involving Montefiore associates (or their data) as a target population Fran Ganz-Lord or
Michaela Catalano
ohs@montefiore.org

The following committee approvals are required before the study may begin.:

Committee Name Required For Contact
Embryonic Stem Cell Research Oversight (ESCRO) Committee Any research on gametes and blastocysts, including human embryonic stem cell research (hESC). Please note that ESCRO review may lead to modifications of the research protocol. Melissa Epstein
718.430.2237
Magnetic Resonance Research Center (MRRC) Committee Any research involving the MRRC facility, prior to initiation the MRRC component of the study. Please note that MRRC review may lead to modifications of the research protocol. Luda Slobodskaya
718.430.3323
NBHN Research Protocol Working Group (RPWG) and HHC Any research involving HHC/NYMA/NBHN/JMC/NCB personnel, facilities, and/or resources. Howard Nadel
718.918.7070